infolinks

Ipinapakita ang mga post na may etiketa na Church Of christ. Ipakita ang lahat ng mga post
Ipinapakita ang mga post na may etiketa na Church Of christ. Ipakita ang lahat ng mga post

Huwebes, Oktubre 1, 2015

Ilan Ang Tunay na Diyos ayon sa Bibliya?

Maraming Relihiyon ngayon ang nagsasabing si Cristo daw ay Diyos. Sa makatuwid, Dalawa na ang Diyos nila? Ang Ama at ang kanyang anak na si Cristo. Ating suriin, ilan ang tunay na Diyos ayon sa Bibliya?
"Kung ang Ama ang iisang Diyos ayon sa inyong doktrina, bakit ang nakasulat sa Awit 82:1 at 6 ay "siya'y humahatol sa gitna ng MGA DIYOS" at "Kayo'y MGA DIYOS".? At bukod dito, Ano naman ang pinagkaiba kung mayroong maraming tunay na diyos? hindi ba masmabuti kung maraming diyos? tulad ng kasabihang "the more the merrier"?"
Awit 82:1,6 "Ang Dios ay tumatayo sa kapisanan ng Dios; siya'y humahatol sa gitna ng mga dios.
Aking sinabi, Kayo'y mga dios, at kayong lahat ay mga anak ng Kataastaasan."
Ang salitang "mga diyos" sa talatang ito ay tumutukoy sa mga taong inilagay ng Diyos bilang mga hukom at mga pinuno sa bayang Israel. Sa panahon ng bayang Israel, ang mga hukom ay tinatawag na "mga diyos" bagaman sila ay mga tao. Sila'y tinatawag na "mga diyos" hindi dahil sa sila ay mga tunay na diyos sa kalikasan, kundi sila'y itinalaga ng Diyos upang isagawa ang paghatol ng Diyos sa kaniyang bayan. Ang halimbawa nito ay ang nakasulat sa Exodo 21:6, ganito ang ating mababasa:
Exodus 21:6 "then his master shall bring him unto God, and shall bring him to the door, or unto the door-post; and his master shall bore his ear through with an awl; and he shall serve him for ever." American Standard Version
sa Filipino:
"Kung magkagayo'y dadalhin siya ng kaniyang panginoon sa Dios, at dadalhin siya sa pinto, o sa haligi ng pinto; at bubutasan ng kaniyang panginoon ang kaniyang tainga ng isang pangbutas; at paglilingkuran niya siya magpakailan man."
Ganito ang pagkakasalin naman ng King James Version sa ganun ding talata:
Exodus 21:6 "Then his master shall bring him unto the judges; he shall also bring him to the door, or unto the door post; and his master shall bore his ear through with an aul; and he shall serve him for ever." King James Version
sa Filipino:
"Kung magkagayo'y dadalhin siya ng kaniyang panginoon sa mga hukom, at dadalhin siya sa pinto, o sa haligi ng pinto; at bubutasan ng kaniyang panginoon ang kaniyang tainga ng isang pangbutas; at paglilingkuran niya siya magpakailan man."
Pansining mabuti na ang salitang "diyos" sa talata ay ginamit upang tumukoy sa "mga hukom". Sa parehong kaparaanan, ang "kapisanan ng Diyos" na binanggit sa Awit 82:1 at 6 ay tumutukoy sa mga hukom ng bayang Israel-at hindi sa maraming mga diyos na para bagang mayroong higit sa isang Diyos. Isa pang katunayan na ang salitang "mga diyos" sa Awit 82:1 at 6 ay tumutukoy sa mga hukom ay ang katotohanan na sila'y hinatulan ng tunay na Diyos na sila ay mangamamatay tulad ng tao:
Awit 82:2,7 "“Dapat ninyong itigil na, paghatol na hindi tama, Tumigil na ng paghatol na panig sa masasama.
Ngunit tulad nitong tao, lahat kayo’y mamamatay; Katulad din ng prinsipe, papanaw ang inyong buhay." Magandang Balita Biblia
Ang "mga diyos" sa Awit 82:1 at 6 ay hindi maaaring gamitin upang patotohanan lamang ng pagkamarami ng diyos. Ang paniniwala sa maraming diyos ay sumasalungat sa mga itinuturo ng Bibla na mayroon lamang iisang Diyos bagama't maraming tinatawag na mga diyos, sa mga tunay na Christiano ay iisa lamang ang Diyos:
1 Corinto 8:5-6 "Bagamat may sinasabing mga diyos sa langit o sa lupa, at maraming tinatawag na “mga diyos” at “mga panginoon,”
sa ganang atin ay iisa lamang ang Diyos, ang Ama na lumikha ng lahat ng bagay, at tayo’y nabubuhay para sa kanya. Iisa ang Panginoon, si Jesu-Cristo, at sa pamamagitan niya’y nilikha ang lahat ng bagay at sa pamamagitan din niya’y nabubuhay tayo." Magandang Balita
Sapagkat ito ang ipinahayag mismo ng Diyos sa kaniyang mga nilalang:
Isaias 46:9 "Dili-dilihin ninyo Ang matagal nang nakaraan. Inyong kilalaning ako lamang ang Diyos, At liban sa akin ay wala nang iba." Magandang Balita
Ang Diyos na ang nagpakilala sa kaniyang sarili na Siya lamang ang dapat nating kikilalaning Diyos at liban sa kaniya ay wala ng iba. Paano kung kumilala tayo ng ibang Diyos maliban sa Ama?
Exodo 20:3 "Huwag kayong magkakaroon ng ibang diyos, maliban sa akin." Magandang Balita
Maliwanag na mahigipit na pinagbabawal ng Diyos sa kaniyang mga lingkosd na kumilala ng ibang diyos maliban sa kaniya. Sapagkat malinaw Niyang ipinahayag na Siya lamang ang Diyos at wala ng iba.
Napakahalaga sa isang tao na magkaroon ng kaalaman tungkol sa Diyos. Ayon sa ating Panginoong Jesucristo na ang sumampalataya at kilalanin na ang Ama ang iisa at tunay na Diyos ay may buhay na walang hanggan:
Juan 17:1,3 "Pagkasabi ni Jesus ng mga pananalitang ito, tumingala siya sa langit at kanyang sinabi, "Ama, dumating na ang oras; parangalan mo na ang iyong Anak upang maparangalan ka niya.
Ito ang buhay na walang hanggan: ang makilala ka nila, ang iisa at tunay na Diyos, at ang makilala si Jesu-Cristo na iyong isinugo." Bagong Magandang Balita
Sa kabilang banda, sa mga taong hindi wasto ang pagkakilala tungkol sa Diyos ay paparusahan:
2 Tesalonica 1:8-9 "Na maghihiganti sa hindi nagsisikilala sa Dios, at sa kanila na hindi nagsisitalima sa evangelio ng ating Panginoong Jesus:
Na siyang tatanggap ng kaparusahan, na walang hanggang kapahamakang mula sa harapan ng Panginoon at mula sa kaluwalhatian ng kaniyang kapangyarihan."
Ang tunay na Christiano ay kumikilala lamang sa iisang Diyos, walang iba kundi ang Ama lamang sapagkat ito ang itinuro ng Panginoong Jesus at ipinahayag ng Panginoong Diyos. (2023)

Miyerkules, Setyembre 30, 2015

IS JOINING THE IGLESIA NI CRISTO A BAD IDEA?


Mr. Isahel N. Alfonso, a Roman Catholic apologist and blogger, a member of the Catholic Faith Defenders (CFD) in the Archdiocese of Davao wrote an article which he called WHY JOINING THE IGLESIA NI CRISTO IS A BAD IDEA. Although his arguments are just a rehash of what has been used by CFDs before him against the Iglesia Ni Cristo, I decided to answer his allegations so that he could not deceive our Catholic and Protestant friends who are in the process of joining the Church. As I look at his arguments, some were simply copied and pasted from other Catholic websites.
First, let us take a look at his arguments then let us provide the answers so he and his co-defenders may be enlightened and hopefully, will join the chorus of Catholics who are in exodus and now are finding their way into the Iglesia Ni Cristo.
ARGUMENT NUMBER ONE
1. The Iglesia Ni Cristo (INC) was founded by Felix Manalo, not by Jesus Christ.
The Iglesia Ni Cristo apologists rely on a single Bible text to prove that INC is the true Church of Jesus Christ. According to them since the name of their Church is "Church of Christ", and in Romans 16:16 we can read "Churches of Christ" therefore, theirs is the true Church of Jesus Christ since the name of their Church can literally be found in the Bible. This argument cannot hold water for two reasons,
1. If the name of the Church is the basis of its authenticity then the INC have to accept that other Protestant denominations that got its name from the pages of Scripture must also be a true Church of Jesus Christ. 2. The authenticity (or being the true Church) relies not on its name but whether it is personally of historically founded by Jesus Christ.
ANSWERS TO ARGUMENT NUMBER ONE:
It seems that Mr. Alfonso is outdated when it comes to the issue of the verses that are being used by the Iglesia Ni Cristo to prove that the name of the Church built by Christ is the Church of Christ. He said that we are just using a single text to prove that the true Church is called by the name Church of Christ. He cited Romans 16:16 then concluded by saying that “if the name of the Church is the basis of its authenticity then the INC have to accept that other Protestant denominations that got its name from the pages of Scripture must also be a true Church of Jesus Christ.”
First, it is not true that only Romans 16:16 mention the name Church of Christ in the Bible.Below are some translations into English and Spanish that contain the name Church of Christ, proving that Mr. Alfonso's arguments really cannot hold water. His argument is flawed and inconsistent.
Before we go to the different translations of the Bible that contain the term, I would let a Catholic author, a Jesuit priest, to educate him on the issue of the name of the Church established by Christ. Let’s analyze the points he raised:
5. Did Jesus Christ establish a Church?
“Yes, from all history, both secular and profane, as well as from the Bible considered as a human document, we learn that Jesus Christ established a Church, which from the earliest times has been called after Him the Christian Church or the Church of Christ.” (Cassily, Francis B., S.J. Religion: Doctrine and Practice for use in Catholic High Schools. 12th and revised edition. Imprimi Potest: Charles H. Cloud, S.J. Provincial of the Chicago Province. Imprimatur: George Cardinal Mundelein, Archbishop of Chicago. Chicago: Loyola University Press, 1934, pp. 442-443.).
We agree with this priest's contention that the Church established by Christ was called after him, the CHURCH OF CHRIST. We believe what he is saying, not because he is a priest, but because he said that it is from the Bible that “we learn that Jesus Christ established a Church, which from the earliest times has been called after Him the Christian Church or the Church of Christ.”
Obviously, Mr. Alfonso did not learn from his mentor and does not know that the Bible teaches that the name of the Church established by Jesus Christ is called the Church of Christ. If the Roman Catholic Church where he belongs is the true Church and not the Church of Christ, how come it is not written in the Bible? Does it mean that Mr. Alfonso’s church is not true and he is a member of a false church? You know the answer to these questions.
To show his ignorance, I am going to cite the translations of the Bible that have the term “Church of Christ” so he may learn not to jump to a hasty conclusion that only Romans 16:16 mentions the term. He probably needs to study more before he would say anything that would just make him laughable at the end. Here is one verse and the translations that proved them:
ACTS 20:28 LAMSA TRANSLATION
Take heed therefore to yourselves and to all the flock over which the Holy Spirit has appointed your overseers, to feed the church of Christ which he has purchased with his blood."
ACTS 20:28 ETHERIDGE TRANSLATION
Take heed therefore to yourselves, and to the whole flock over which the Spirit of Holiness hath constituted you the bishops; to pasture the church of the Meshiha [Christ] which he hath purchased with his blood.
ACTS 20:28 DISCIPLES NEW TESTAMENT
Therefore, take care of yourselves, and of all the congregation in which you have been appointed through the holy Spirit as bishops, to shepherd the church of Jesus Christ, that which he established by his blood.
ACTS 20:28 BIBLIA PESHITTA
Por tanto, tengan cuidado de ustedes mismos, y de todo el rebaño sobre el cual los ha puesto el Espíritu Santo como supervisores para apacentar la iglesia del Cristo, la cual Él compró con su sangre.
With the preponderance of biblical texts that show the term CHURCH OF CHRIST, they tell us that Mr. Alfonso’s arguments are unfounded.
We do not say that the name alone identifies the true Church. It’s true that there are some Protestant churches that use the name Church of Christ. However, the identity of the true Church is that it is not only named or written in the Bible but the teachings that it embraces must be in the Bible. That’s the problem with Protestant churches and especially the Catholic Church where Mr. Alfonso belongs since their doctrines and practices are against the teachings of the Bible. Please read my postings on THE TRINITY AND INCARNATION: TRUTH OR FALLACY? and you will see that the Catholic and Protestant doctrine about God and His Son Jesus Christ is flawed and directly contradicts genuine biblical teaching.
In our next article, we shall show to Mr. Alfonso why we believe that the true Church is not only named after Christ but it is personally founded by Jesus Christ. He will have the opportunity to know that the Iglesia Ni Cristo which emerged in the Philippiness in 1914 was established by Christ himself. Who knows, he might be enlightened and join the Church of Christ but first, he should sit down and listen as our ministers will teach him from the Bible the truth about the re-establishment of the true Church of Christ in the Philippines. Like the millions who joined the Iglesia Ni Cristo, he will have the confindence that he is indeed a member of the true Church of Christ. (2023)

THE REASON WHY IT IS THE DUTY OF THE IGLESIA NI CRISTO TO MAKE KNOWN THE TRUE GOD THAT MUST BE WORSHIPPED. Why was the Iglesia Ni Cristo singled out to carry on this task?

(c) Bro. Jose Ventilacion
Are you worshipping the true God?
If you consider yourself a religious person, you would most likely respond in the affirmative if asked if you are worshiping the true God. You probably believe that the divine being to whom you render religious services is the true God. However, if the God that you believe in is not one but three distinct beings, each one of whom is supposed to be God, and called by the term Trinity, how certain are you that you are worshiping the true God?
If your idea of God is different from the notion of those who believe in the Trinity because you think that the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit are just three manifestations of the one true God, which is what the adherents of the so-called “Oneness” doctrine teach, how confident are you that you have the right knowledge of God and are worshiping the true God? If you are one of those who believe in many gods and goddesses each of whom is manifesting particular divine attributes or caring for some particular aspects of nature or of human affairs, then you a polytheist. Polytheism was a form of religion in the ancient world and was well developed in Egypt, Mesopotamia, Greece, Rome, and elsewhere. If you worship deities, are you in reality worshiping the true God?
It behooves us to examine carefully this subject so that we will know for certain who indeed, is the true God that must be worshipped. It would be an exercise in futility if we render a worship service but find out later that such pious act is being offered to the wrong God!
Many people today realize that it is indeed man’s inherent obligation to serve and worship God. The proliferation of religions all over the world attests to the truth that man indeed has understood that worship of God is essential and necessary. As the Scriptures say:
“Worship the Lord with gladness; come before him with joyful songs. Know that the Lord is God. It is he who made us, and we are his; we are his people, the sheep of his pasture” (Ps. 100:2-3 NIV).
Indeed, man is duty-bound to worship his Creator, but he must recognize the identity of the true God. Should man believe in many gods manifested in myriads of form or in only one God? We must consult the Holy Scriptures to determine if we are indeed worshiping the true God.
The one true God
In Deuteronomy 6:4, Moses told his fellow Israelites:
“Hear, 0 Israel: The LORD our God, the LORD is one!”
Even during the time of Moses, the Israelites clung to the belief that there is only one God. By upholding the belief that God is one, they necessarily opposed the worship of other gods (Exod. 20:3-5). In fact, it is God Himself who wanted them to know that He is the only true God as Moses said in Deuteronomy 4:35:
“The Lord wants you to know he is the only true God, and he wants you to obey him ...” (CEV).
The true God Himself declared to the Israelites that “there is no other God” besides Him. Through the prophet Isaiah, He said:
“Remember the former things, those of long ago; I am God, and there is no other; I am God, and there is none like me.” (Isa. 46:9, NIV).
“I am the LORD, and there is no other; apart from me there is no God. I will strengthen you, though you have not acknowledged me, so that from the rising of the sun to the place of its setting men may know there is none besides me. I am the LORD, and there is no other.” (Isa. 45:5-6, Ibid.)
When God speaks, He alone is speaking. He is not speaking as one God among the three, as the Trinity doctrine suggests. Those who are worshiping a triune God are not worshiping the true God.
The ubiquitous and eternal God is the Father
God Himself wants all people to realize that He is the God of everyone and that He is not a God in just a certain place but in all places. As Moses told the Israelites:
“Know therefore this day and keep in mind that the LORD alone is God in heaven above and on earth below; there is no other.” (Deuteronomy 4:39 JPS).
The prophet Jeremiah proclaimed to his fellow Israelites that the true God is not only one but is also eternal. Thus, he announced in Jeremiah 10:10:
“But the LORD is the only true God, the living God. He is the everlasting King!” (NLT).
Even at the close of the Old Testament period, the prophet Malachi declared that there is only one God. He likewise proclaimed that the one God is the Father:
“Have we not all one Father? Did not one God create us? . . . (Malachi 2:10, NIV)
The same teaching was taught by Isaiah when he proclaimed the virtues of God. He said:
“But now, O LORD, you are our Father; We are the clay, and You are the Potter, We are all the work of Your hands” (Isaiah 64:7, JPS).
The Israelites recognized the Father as the only true God There was no mention in the Old Testament of a triune God—Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, as one God. It is ridiculous and absurd to teach that the Israelites believed in more than one God, that is, other than the Father, they recognized two more gods—the Son and the Holy Spirit!
The true God in the Christian era
However, some theologians say that this concept of the Father being the only true God is no longer true during the New Testament period; they aver that when Jesus came, He taught that there is a plurality of persons subsisting in the one true God! Wayne Grudem asserts this in his book, Systematic Theology, page 230:
“When the New Testament opens, we enter into the history of the coming of the Son of God on earth. It is to be expected that this great event would be accompanied by more explicit teaching about the trinitarian nature of God, and that is in fact what we find.”
If this statement were correct, then we would expect to find in the New Testament explicit teaching about the Trinity. However, the author of the book was honest enough and quick to admit at the beginning of his discourse on the Trinity that the term itself could not be found in the Bible:
“The word trinity is never found in the Bible” (p. 226, Ibid.)
Instead, what we find in the New Testament are clear teachings that uphold the absolute oneness of God, as revealed in the Old Testament. Let’s take a closer look at what Jesus Himself stated when He was praying to God. In John 17:1, 3, this is recorded:
“When Jesus finished saying all these things, he looked up to heaven and said, ‘Father, the time has come. Glorify your Son so he can give glory back to you . . . And this is the way to have eternal life – to know you, the only true God, and Jesus Christ, the one you sent to earth’” (NLT).
The true Christian doctrine, as expounded by Jesus Christ Himself, is that there is only one true God and He is the Father. Jesus emphasized the absolute oneness of God by the use of the term “only.” To Jesus, His Father is the only God that His disciples should know, as He reiterated in John 5:44-45:
“You like to receive praise from one another, but you do not try to win praise from the one who alone is God; how, then, can you believe me? Do not think, however, that I am the one who will accuse you to my Father” (TEV).
Verse 45 tells us that the only God is the Father, corroborating the other statement of Jesus in 17:1 and 3 that the Father is the only true God. This is the true Christian doctrine. Any teaching which opposes this should be considered as false and diverts one from having the knowledge of the true God taught in the Bible.
Christ’s apostles, particularly Apostle Paul, did teach and emphasize that the Father is the only God. In his first epistle to the Corinthians, Apostle Paul declared the obvious and glaring difference between genuine Christians and those who also believe in the existence of gods, which of course, are false ones. In chapter 8 verses 5 and 6, he declared:
“There may be so-called gods both in heaven and on earth, and some people actually worship many gods and many lords. But we know that there is only one God, the Father, who created everything, and we live for him. And there is only one Lord, Jesus Christ, through whom God made everything and through whom we have been given life” (NLT).
Apostle Paul knew the gods in the Greek pantheon, the chief of whom they called Zeus. In fact, he was once mistaken for Hermes, while his companion, Barnabas, was mistakenly thought of as Zeus (Acts 14:8-12), so that when he wrote to the Christians in Corinth, he told them that if other people such as the Greeks believed in many gods and many lords, for the Christians and for himself, being true Christians and possessors of the true knowledge of God, there is only one God and He is the Father (Eph. 4:4-6).
If you worship a God different from the God worshiped by the true Christians, you are not worshiping the true God. Today, throughout the world, various concepts and beliefs are being held by people concerning deities that are made of gold, silver and stone. The Bible is clear in saying that those who hold on to a concept of a god represented by various forms could not qualify as children of the true God. Apostle Paul said to the Athenians:
“Therefore, since we are the offspring of God, we ought not to think that the Divine Nature is like gold or silver or stone, something shaped by art and man's devising. Truly, these times of ignorance God overlooked, but now commands all men everywhere to repent” (Acts 17:29).
People became ignorant of the identity of the true God, substituting Him with images made by hands and treating them as gods. No wonder Paul made an explicit and straightforward statement about these people when he wrote to the Romans that these people “became futile in their thoughts, and their foolish hearts were darkened. Professing to be wise, they became fools, and changed the glory of the incorruptible God into an image made like corruptible man — and birds and four-footed animals and creeping things.” (Romans 1:22-23) The same people “exchanged the truth of God for the lie; and worshiped and served the creature rather than the Creator” (Rom. 1:25 Ibid.).
To whom the true knowledge of God is given
Although from ancient times, “what may be known of God is manifest in them, for God has shown it to them. For since the creation of the world His invisible attributes are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even His eternal power and Godhead, so that they are without excuse (Rom. 1:18-19 Ibid.), still the world does not know God. It is for this reason that Jesus Christ came – to make known to them and to us who the true God is (1st John 5:20), as He emphasized in His prayer:
“Righteous Father, though the world does not know you, I know you, and they know that you have sent me. I have made you known to them, and will continue to make you known in order that the love you have for me may be in them and that I myself may be in them.” (John 17:25-26 NIV).
Notice that there are people to whom Jesus Christ has made known the identity of the true God. These are the people whom the Father has given to Christ (v.9). How they were given by God to Christ was explained by Apostle Paul. He said:
“God is to be trusted, the God who called you to have fellowship with his Son Jesus Christ, our Lord.” (I Cor. 1:9 GNT).
Those who were given by God to Christ were called in order for them to have fellowship with the Lord. Apostle Paul explained also that those who were called are found in the body or in the Church (Col. 1:18; 3:15), the Church of Christ (Acts 20:28 Lamsa Translation).
The members of the true Church are the ones who now possess the true knowledge about God. Today, the Iglesia ni Cristo proclaims to the world that there is no other true God except the Father. Why was the Iglesia ni Cristo singled out to carry on this task? God, through the prophet Isaiah, declared:
“The Lord says, "You are my witnesses and the servant I chose. I chose you so you would know and believe me, so you would understand that I am the true God. There was no God before me, and there will be no God after me . . .” (Isaiah 43:10 NCV).
God has brought people from the East and from the West to serve as His witnesses testifying that there is only one true God (Isa. 43:5-6 Moffatt Translation), that there is no God before Him and there will be no God after Him. This is the God whom the members of the Iglesia ni Cristo worship and praise.
If you want your worship to become acceptable to God, recognize and worship no other God except the true God of the Bible, the Father in heaven, the Creator of heaven and earth and all therein that is in them. To recognize Him as such is the way to have eternal life (John 17:3 NLT).
All Scriptural quotations are from the New King James Version unless otherwise specified. (2023)

MALILIGTAS BA ANG MGA NATIWALAG SA IGLESIA NI CRISTO? ANO NAMAN ANG MANGYAYARI SA MGA KUSANG LUMABAS O ITINIWALAG ANG SARILI?

(c) Bro. Jose Ventilacion
Kamakailan ay may mga natiwalag sa Iglesia na ang paniniwala ay maliligtas din sila sa kaparusahan pagdating ng Araw ng Paghuhukom. Ang akala naman ng iba ay maliligtas din sila dahil sa hindi naman daw sila itiniwalag kungdi kusa silang tumiwalag. Gayunman, ang mga itiniwalag at kusang tumiwalag ay pareho ang kalagayan: nasa labas sila ng tunay na Iglesia. May kaligtasan ba sa mga nasa labas? Ano naman ang sinasabi ng Biblia sa mga nasa labas ng Iglesia?
Ayon sa 1 Corinto 5:13, ibinilin ng Diyos sa Pamamahala ng Iglesia na “alisin nga ninyo sa inyo ang masamang tao” (DS). Ang katumbas ng “alisin” ay “itiwalag” ayon sa saling MB.
Ikinakatuwiran ng mga itiniwalag na hindi raw sila kabilang sa “masasamang tao” dahil para daw sa ikabubuti ng Iglesia ang kanilang layunin at ipinakikipaglaban o itinataguyod. Subalit alam naman natin na kahit ano pa ang kanilang ikinakatuwiran – na hindi sila masama – kaya sila itiniwalag ay mayroon silang ginawang masama. Ititiwalag ba sila sa Iglesia kung tama ang kanilang ginawa? Mali ba ang ginawa ng Pamamahala na sila ay alisin sa kalipunan ng mga matuwid? Tama ba ang kanilang ginawa?
Ang paghihimagsik ba laban sa Pamamahala ay mabuti o masama? Mabuti ba ang paghahasik ng pagkakabaha-bahagi? Mabuti bang gawa ang paninirang-puri sa mga ministro at mga manggagawa? Mabuting gawa ba ang paghikayat sa mga kapatid na huwag na silang sumamba o kaya ay huwag nang mag-abuloy? Mabuti bang gawa ang sabihin sa mga kapatid na huwag na silang tumulong sa pagpapalaganap ng salita ng Diyos
Ang mga nahulog sa mga kasalanang binanggit ko sa itaas ang dahilan kaya sila ay natiwalag sa Iglesia. Kaya, bagamat naghuhugas sila ng kamay at nangangatuwiran na “mabuti” daw ang kanilang ginawa, ang mga natiwalag ayon sa Biblia ay hindi mga mabubuting tao kungdi mga “masamang kasamahan” (1 Corinto 5:13 NPV).
Ayon din sa talatang ito, ang mga nasa labas ay may hatol. Ano ang hatol sa mga nasa labas ayon kay Cristo? Ang mga hindi nanatili ay masusunog sa apoy (Juan 15:6). Kailan? Sa Araw ng Paghuhukom ayon sa 2 Pedro 3:7, 10.
Ang ikinakatuwiran naman ng iba ay: “tao lang ang nagtiwalag sa amin, hindi ang Diyos, kaya maliligtas pa rin kami.” Dahil ba sa ang Pamamahala na nagtiwalag sa kanila ay tao, nangangahulugan nang hindi sila itiniwalag ng Diyos? Paano ba nagtitiwalag ang Diyos ng mga masasama? Siya ba mismo ang mananaog sa lupa para sabihin ng personal sa mga masasama na sila ay itinitiwalag?
Sa panahon ng unang Iglesia, sino ba ang nag-utos na ang bilin niya ay “itiwalag ninyo ang masamang kasamahan ninyo”? Diyos ba ang nagsalita sa talatang ito o tao lang? Ang sumulat ng talatang ito ay si Apostol Pablo. Siya ay tao. Subalit siya ba ang nag-utos ng isinulat niya?
Ang sabi pa niya ay “Ganito ang sabi ng Kasulatan.” Samakatuwid, ang utos na ito ay may pinanggalingang kasulatan. Aling kasulatan ang sinipi ni Apostol Pablo? Ang utos ng Diyos sa pamamagitan ni Moises na nakasulat sa Deuteronomio 17:7 (NPV), na ganito ang sinasabi:
“DAPAT ALISIN SA KALIPUNAN NINYO ANG MGA TAONG MASASAMA.”
Kaya, ang isinulat ni Apostol Pablo na “ALISIN NGA NINYO SA INYO ANG MASAMANG TAO.” (1 Corinto 5:13 DS) o "ITIWALAG NINYO ANG MASAMANG KASAMAHAN NINYO" (1 Corinto 5:13 MB) ay utos ng Diyos na nakasulat sa Biblia sa panahon pa lamang ni Moises.
Sino ang kinasangkapan ng Diyos noong una para matupad ang utos Niya na ALISIN o ITIWALAG ang mga masasamang tao sa bayan Niya? Ganito ang sinasabi ng Kasulatan sa Bilang 16:23-27 NPV:
23 Sinabi ng PANGINOON kay MOISES. 24 “Sabihin mo sa kapulungang lumayo kina Core, Datan at Abiram.” 25 Pinuntahan ni Moses sina Datan at Abiram. Sumunod sa kanya ang matatanda sa Israel. 26 Sinabi niya sa kapulungan, “lumayo kayo sa tolda ng mga suwail na ito! Huwag ninyong sasalingin man lang ang anumang ari-arian nila pagkat pati kayo’y malilipol dahil sa kanilang mga kasalanan.” 27 Lumayo nga sila sa tolda ni Core, Datan at Abiram. Sina Datan at Abiram ay nakatayo sa pintuan ng kani-kaniyang tolda, kasama ng kani-kanilang asawa’t mga anak.
Ang Panginoong Diyos ay inutusan si Moises kasama ang mga matatanda sa Israel. Sinabihan niya ang kapulungan na lumayo o humiwalay sa mga suwail na sina Core, Datan, at Abiram. Ang terminong SUWAIL sa NPV ay isinalin na MASASAMANG TAO (DS) o UBOD NG SASAMA (MB).
Kaya ang Diyos ang may utos ng pagtitiwalag at hindi ang tao. Kapag may itinitiwalag sa Iglesia ay maling isipin na tao lang ang nagtitiwalag. Ginagamit ng Diyos ang Pamamahala na inilagay Niya sa Iglesia upang ito ay isagawa. Ganiyan ang ginawa Niya noong una, ginamit ng Diyos ang taong si Moises para sabihin ang Kaniyang pasiya na humiwalay ang Kaniyang bayan sa mga suwail o masasamang tao, kaya ganito din ang ginagawa Niya ngayon sa Iglesia.
Kung ang lider noon ng bayang Israel ay si MOISES, ngayon naman ay si Kapatid na EDUARDO V. MANALO. Kung may mga kasamang MATATANDA si Moises, mayroon ding kasamang matatanda si Ka Eduardo na ang tawag ay SANGGUNIAN. Subalit tandan natin na hindi ang mga matatanda ang nagsalita sa kapulungan kungdi si Moises. Sa panahon naman natin, si Kapatid na Eduardo ang nagsalita sa pamamagitan ng circular letter o sulat niya sa lahat ng mga Iglesia Ni Cristo na itinitiwalag ang mga masasamang tao sa Iglesia. Iniutos din niya sa atin na humiwalay sa mga suwail batay sa utos ng Diyos na nakasulat sa Biblia:
9 Hindi pinananahanan ng Diyos ang sinumang lumalabis sa halip na mananatili sa turo ni Cristo. Sinumang nanatili sa turo ay kinaroroonan ng Ama at ng Anak. 10 Huwag ninyong papapasukin o tatanggapin sa inyong bahay ang sinumang lumalapit na hindi ito ang dalang aral. 11 Sinumang magpatuloy sa kanya ay nakikihati sa kanyang masamang gawa (2 Juan 1:9-11 NPV).
Pinarusahan ng Diyos noon ang mga suwail o masasamang tao pagkatapos na sila ay mahiwalay sa kapulungan ng Israel. Bumuka ang lupa at nilamon ng lupa ang sambahayan ni Core at ang kaniyang mga pag-aari (Bilang 16:31-33). Bumaba ang apoy mula sa langit at sinunog ang 250 saserdote na nagsusunog ng kamangyan (talatang 35). Ano naman ang gagawin ng Diyos sa mga natiwalag sa panahon natin?
ANO ANG PARUSA SA MGA NATIWALAG?
Ayon din sa 1 Corinto 5:13, ang mga nasa labas ay may hatol. Ano ang hatol sa mga nasa labas ayon kay Cristo? Ang mga hindi nanatili ay masusunog sa apoy (Juan 15:6). Kailan? Sa Araw ng Paghuhukom ayon sa 2 Pedro 3:7, 10.
Sa mga natiwalag kamakailan, nais ba ninyong sapitin ang ganitong kapalaran? Kung nais ninyong maligtas, magbalikloob kayo sa Diyos. Magpilit kayong pumasok na muli sa loob ng Iglesia para kayo maalis sa kalagayang may hatol. Huwag ninyong dayain ang inyong sarili sa paraang iniisip ninyo na maliligtas din ang nasa labas ng Iglesia. Wala kayong mababasa sa Biblia na kapag nasa labas ay may kaligtasan. Ang kailangan ay makabalik kayo sa loob ng Iglesia at matiyagang manatili hanggang sa wakas upang kayo ay maligtas (Mateo 24:13).
ANO NAMAN ANG KAPALARAN NG MGA NAGTIYAGA NA MANATILI SA IGLESIA NI CRISTO PAGDATING NG ARAW NG PAGHUHUKOM?
“Sa panahong iyon ay tatayo si Miguel, ang dakilang pinuno na tagapag-ingat ng iyong bayan. At magkakaroon ng panahon ng kaguluhan na hindi pa nangyari kailanman mula nang magkaroon ng bansa hanggang sa panahong iyon. Ngunit sa panahong iyon ay maliligtas ang iyong bayan, bawat isa na ang pangalan ay matatagpuang nakasulat sa aklat” (Daniel 12:1 ABAB).
Ang panahon ng kaguluhan ay ang Araw ng Panginoon o Araw ng Paghuhukom (Zefanias 1:14-18; 2 Pedro 3:7, 10). Ang bayan ng Diyos sa mga huling araw na ito o sa panahong malapit na ang wakas o sa “mga wakas ng lupa” ay ang Iglesia Ni Cristo na lumitaw sa Pilipinas sa bisa ng mga hula at sa pagsusugo ng Diyos kay Kapatid na FELIX Y. MANALO (Isaias 62:11-12; 43:5-6; 41:9-10). Kaya ang mga nasa loob ng Iglesia Ni Cristo ang mga maliligtas at hindi ang mga nasa labas o natiwalag.
Sinong nasa bayan ng Diyos ang maliligtas? Sapat na bang nabautismuhan lang sa Iglesia Ni Cristo? Hindi. Ang mga maliligtas na Iglesia Ni Cristo ay ang mga kaanib na ang pangalan nila ay matatagpuang nakasulat sa aklat. Ito ang AKLAT NG BUHAY.
Burahin Ninyo ang pangalan nila sa Inyong Aklat ng Buhay; hindi sana sila masama sa mga matuwid (Awit 69:28, Buhay na Salita).
Itala mong lahat ang kanilang sala, Sa mangaliligtas, huwag silang isama (Awit 69:27 NPV).
Ang mga natiwalag sa Iglesia ay binura o inalis ang kanilang mga pangalan sa aklat ng buhay sa langit kaya hindi sila maliligtas. Ayon sa Biblia ay itatapon sa apoy ang hindi nakasulat sa aklat ng buhay (Apocalipsis 20:15). Ang Diyos mismo ang nag-aalis ng mga pangalan nila sa aklat (Exodus 32:31-33).
SA MGA NASA LOOB NA NG IGLESIA NI CRISTO, NAIS BA NINYONG MANATILING NAKATALA SA AKLAT NG BUHAY?
Ano ang isa sa mga gawaing nilalahukan ng mga masisiglang Iglesia Ni Cristo, na kapag nagpagal sa gawaing ito ay tinitiyak ng Biblia na maliligtas dahil ang kanilang pangalan ay nakasulat sa aklat ng buhay? Basahin natin ang ipinahayag ni Apostol Pablo:
Ipinapakiusap ko rin naman sa iyo, tapat kong kasama, na tulungan mo ang dalawang babaing ito. Sila man ay kasama kong nagpagal sa pagpapalaganap ng Magandang Balita, kasama si Clemente at ang iba pang kamanggagawa ko. Ang pangalan nila’y nakasulat sa aklat ng buhay (Filipos 4:3 BMB).
Ang pagpapagal para sa pagpapalaganap ng ebanghelyo ay hindi isang kalugihan para sa mga tunay na Iglesia Ni Cristo sapagkat tiniyak sa Biblia na ang mga nagpagal sa gawaing ito, kasama ng mga ministro at mga manggagawa sa Iglesia Ni Cristo, ay tiyak na maliligtas dahil sa ang kanilang mga pangalan ay nakasulat sa aklat ng buhay.
Ang mga natiwalag ay tiyak na hindi na sasama sa gawaing ito dahil sa wala naman silang pagkakilala na maliligtas ang mga papasok at mananatili sa Iglesia Ni Cristo hanggang sa wakas. Ang iba nga ay nang-uupat pa at sinasabi na nagsasayang lang tayo ng panahon kapag tayo ay sumasama sa mga gawain. Ang hindi nila alam ay ginagamit sila ng diablo upang hadlangan ang gawaing pagliligtas. Sino ba ang ayaw na ang tao ay maligtas? Di ba ang diablo? Papayag ba tayo, mga kapatid, na mahadlangan ng diablo?
Sa darating na September 26, 2015 ay isasagawa natin ang pambuong mundo na pagpapalaganap ng ebanghelyo na pangungunahan ng ating Tagapamahalang Pangkalahatan, ang Kapatid na EDUARDO V. MANALO. Makikipagkaisa ba kayo sa gawaing ito? Sana, tayong lahat ay tumugon sa panawagan ng Pamamahala na mag-anyaya ng maraming mga tao na makapakinig ng dalisay na aral ng Diyos upang sila ay makasama natin sa tunay na Iglesia at magtamo ng biyayang kaligtasan. (2023)

THE TRINITY AND THE INCARNATION: TRUTH OR FALLACY?

One of the most misunderstood teachings believed in by the Iglesia Ni Cristo is about the true state of being of Christ. To us, the Lord Jesus Christ is a man (Acts 2:36, 22). People who are not familiar with what we believe about him would react negatively and would easily, without hesitation, classify us as antichrists, even without giving us the chance and opportunity to explain why we believe so. Some have even gone to the point of accusing us that we belittle or denigrate the Lord Jesus Christ because of what we believe about Him.
However, those who gave themselves the chance to ask the reason why the Iglesia Ni Cristo believes such doctrine eventually became members and were strong advocates of the scriptural teaching that Christ is not God. Upon learning the biblical answers to their questions, it became apparent to them that the Iglesia Ni Cristo is correct in believing that Christ is not God.
I made a survey of converts who were formerly Catholics and Protestants when I was assigned in the local congregation of San Francisco, California in 1988. Nine out of ten respondents told me that one of the major doctrines which convinced them to change their religion is the teaching about the true nature of Christ. Although they found it hard to believe that Christ is not God, however, through the biblical evidence that were presented to them by the ministers of the Iglesia Ni Cristo, they were ultimately convinced that their prior belief in Christ was clearly mistaken.
The frequently asked questions are: “why don’t you believe in the Trinity? Why do you believe that Christ is a man?”
The answers to these questions is from Christ himself, as it is written in the book of John wherein it is stated:
40 I am a man who has told you the truth which I heard from God, but you are trying to kill me. Abraham did nothing like that ((John 8:40, NCV).
After we read from the Bible the testimony of Christ about himself that he is a man, many were surprised with this revelation. It was a shocking surprise to some when they learned what Christ taught about himself. They were unaware that Christ introduced himself as a man!
It comes as a surprise since they were told from their early childhood that Christ is God. In fact, Catholics learned about this during their catechism classes and Protestants learned it during their Sunday schools. They did not know that the Bible does not say anything about the so-called divinity of Christ. They were simply told that he is God. It was during the time that they came to the bible study that they learned about Ignatius, a Catholic bishop of Antioch (c. 110 A.D.), was the first one to introduce this unbiblical teaching. Later on, the Council of Nicaea in 325 A.D. made it as an article of faith – that Jesus is truly God (Apostle’s Creed, p. 206).
However, the apostles who succeeded the Lord Jesus Christ continued to teach the doctrine that Christ is a man. We quote below the genuine apostolic teachings about Christ’s true nature:
“People of Israel, listen to these words: Jesus from Nazareth was a very special man. God clearly showed this to you by the miracles, wonders, and signs he did through Jesus. You all know this because it happened right here among you” (Acts 2:22 NCV).
“For there is only one God and one Mediator who can reconcile God and humanity—the man Christ Jesus” (1st Timothy 2:5 NLT).
Apostle Peter says that Jesus is a very special man. Apostle Paul teaches that Christ is a man. They both learned this truth from Christ who said that he is a man.
The statements of the two apostles run contrary to what the Council of Nicea had formulated about Christ. The creed which was ratified in the fourth century states that Christ is true God from true God. You could notice the direct contrast between the apostolic teaching and the Nicene Creed. The apostles said that Christ is a man, not an ordinary man, but a very special man. Apostle Paul taught that Christ is the one Mediator between God and man, and He is truly human. On the other hand, the creed says that Christ is God from God, true God from true God.
It should be clear to everyone interested in this subject that Christ never said that he is God. If he were God, he could have said so when he was still here on earth. However, not only that he did not issue such statement, but he emphatically proclaimed that he is a man telling the truth which he heard from God. So there is a God from whom he heard the truth. Why would he say that he heard it from God if he were that same God?
So, why is Christ not God? It is because the Bible says that God is not a man and man is not God. God’s nature is different from that of man. God is a spirit, a being without flesh and bones. Christ, being a man, has flesh and bones. Take note of his pronouncements about God and about himself in his own words:
“God is a Spirit: and they that worship him must worship him in spirit and in truth” (John 4:24 KJV).
“Behold My hands and My feet, that it is I Myself. Handle Me and see, for a spirit does not have flesh and bones as you see I have” (Luke 24:39).
Christ testified that God is a Spirit while he has flesh and bones. Therefore, since Christ is not a spirit, he is not God.
As presented in the Bible, God, is enormously different from Christ. The pronouncement in Numbers 23:19 is a stark contrast to the pronouncement of Christ in John 9:35-37.
“God is not man, that he should lie, or a son of man, that he should change his mind” (Numbers 23:19 ESV).
35 Jesus heard that they had cast him out and having found him he said, “Do you believe in the Son of Man?” 36 He answered, “And who is he, sir, that I may believe in him?” 37 Jesus said to him, “You have seen him, and it is he who is speaking to you” (John 9:35-37 ESV).
God is not man nor a son of man. Jesus said that he is a son of man, therefore, Jesus is not God.
To counter this argument, Catholic and Protestant apologists would cite the so-called Incarnation of God. Incarnation is a concept that is supposed to mean that God took a human form in the person of Jesus and is intimately connected with the Trinity doctrine. While the doctrine of the Trinity postulates that in one God there are three distinct, divine persons in one godhead – or three beings sharing one nature, on the other hand, the doctrine of incarnation reverses the order by saying that that there are two natures in the one person of Jesus Christ, a doctrine technically called as THE HYPOSTATIC UNION. It is important to understand the formulation of this doctrine since it became the foundation of the Trinity doctrine.
Formulation of the concept
Two of the earliest leading proponents of the so-called incarnation of God were Tertullian (c. 169-230) and Origen (c. 185-254), considered as Church Fathers by the Catholic Church. Their ideas were highly considered when the doctrine of the hypostatic union was formulated into a creed in Chalcedon in 451.
Tertullian, in his work On the Flesh of Christ, says, “Thus the nature of the two substances displayed Him as man and God ... this property of the two states – the divine and the human – is distinctly asserted with equal truth of both natures alike ... The powers of the Spirit proved Him to be God, His sufferings attested the flesh of man” (The Ante-Nicene Fathers, Vol. 3, p. 525).
Origen, in his De Principiis, writes, “Secondly, That Jesus Christ Himself, who came (into the world), was born of the Father before all creatures; that, after He had been the servant of the Father in the creation of all things – ‘For by Him were all things made’ - He in the last times, divesting Himself (of His glory), became a man, and was incarnate although God, and while made a man remained the God which He was; that He assumed a body like to our own, differing in this respect only, that it was born of a virgin and of the Holy Spirit” (The Ante-Nicene Fathers, Vol. 4, p. 240).
Both Tertullian and Origen claimed that Christ had dual nature - He is both man and God. This position had made a significant contribution to the formulation of the doctrine of the Trinity. It can be recalled that it was the Council of Nicea that declared that Jesus Christ is “true God and true man, true God from true God, begotten, not made.” Although unbiblical and incomprehensible, the belief that a true God would come from another God was favored by the more than 250 bishops, was formulated into a creed, and is now believed to be divinely inspired!
In the absence of clear and explicit biblical evidence, such a confounding and absurd doctrine had to rely on faulty inferences. Biblical verses were stretched in the attempt to prove that Jesus is both God and man. In spite of hundreds of years trying to refine it, the incongruity and incoherence still persist, with no lucid and explicit biblical pronouncements to back up the claim.
A complete absurdity
In the light of the Scriptures, one can clearly see the implausibility and the palpable absurdity of the position. The doctrine of Incarnation could not be proven as biblical because it contradicts the teachings of the Bible concerning the attributes of the true God. The Bible teaches that God is immutable, meaning He does not change. Take note of two biblical pronouncements which support this doctrine.
Before the mountains were brought forth, or ever You had formed the earth and the world, even from everlasting to everlasting, You are God (Psalms 90:2).
I am the Lord, and I do not change; and you, children of Jacob, have not perished (Malachi 3:6 CEB).
Even in the New Testament, the apostles continued to uphold the doctrine that God is unchanging or He remains the same in the letter of James. He testified that:
Every good gift and every perfect gift is from above and comes down from the Father of lights, with whom there is no variation or shadow of turning (James 1:17).
So, if Jesus is not God, who is the only one true God? Jesus didactically and emphatically taught about this while uttering his prayer:
“ ... 'Father, the hour has come. Give glory to your Son, so that the Son may give glory to you ... And eternal life means to know you, the only true God, and to know Jesus Christ, whom you sent’” (Jn. 17:1, 3, TEV) (emphasis mine).
Jesus taught through his prayer that the Father is the “only” true God. If there is only one true God and He is the Father, then the Trinity doctrine is nullified by this teaching of Christ. Jesus is not a Trinitarian. He never taught that there are three persons in one God.
The Bible records several instances of Jesus praying to the Father, showing to his disciples that like them, he is a man who needs help from God. The Apostle Paul testified, thus:
“In the days of His flesh, He offered up both prayers and supplications with loud crying and tears to the One able to save Him from death, and He was heard because of His piety” (Hebrews 5:7 NASB).
If it were true that Jesus is both God and man, then his prayer would be nothing less than superficial. It would appear that he was praying to himself, which is truly an inconsistency. And why would Jesus, if he were the same God as the One to whom he was praying, pray to himself? The truth is, Jesus’ prayer is an expression of His dependence on the one God who can save him from death.
The doctrine of the hypostatic union is a matter of prejudice and manifestly absurd because it creates a distorted view about Jesus. Like a jigsaw puzzle whose missing parts could not be found, the arbitrary and convoluted ideas presented to defend it are nowhere to be found in the Scriptures. Its assumptions are inconsistent with the true knowledge about Jesus as presented in the Bible. Take for instance the case when at one point, Jesus acknowledged that:
“But of that day or hour no one knows, not even the angels in heaven, nor the Son, but the Father alone” (Mk. 13:32, Ibid.).
Clearly, Christ is telling us he is not omniscient. Unlike God, Christ does not know the exact day and the hour of his Second Coming. And since Christ is not omniscient, then it appears that if he were God, he could only be so in an inferior and subordinate sense, a clear and gross inconsistency with the alleged equality between the Father and the Son. The verse clearly points to the supremacy of the Father as the Omniscient and the only true God since He alone knows the day and the hour of His Son’s coming.
If it were true that Jesus was God while he was still here on earth and an omnipotent one, how could we reconcile such claim to Christ’s admission in John 14:28 that “... My Father is greater than I”?
Such teaching is consistent with Paul's teaching that “. . . Christ is supreme over every man, the husband is supreme over his wife, and God is supreme over Christ” (1st Corinthians 11:3, TEV). Why would Paul issue such a statement if it were true that [the] God who is supreme over Christ is Jesus himself in a form of a man on earth? Such an inconsistency has left us with no option at all but to treat the doctrine of hypostatic union as a riddle devoid of a solution.
Pushed to the limits, hypostatic union defenders argue that the statement issued by Jesus while he was still on earth should not be construed as utterances by God since they contend that whatever Jesus said or did on earth, he did it as a man. However, after his resurrection, he allegedly came back to his former nature as God. This is short of saying that as a man, Jesus’ words should not be regarded as true but a statement of someone who had perjured himself.
Should we not give credence to his words because they were uttered by a man who has physically existed on earth? Christ himself confirmed that His words are true. Here's what he said:
But as it is, you are seeking to kill Me, a man who has told you the truth, which I heard from God” (John 8:40, NASB).
Granting, without conceding, that Christ was speaking as a man, does it make his statements false? Who could dispute his statement that he is a man telling the truth? Everything that Jesus taught his disciples and was documented in the New Testament is the truth which he heard from God. Will God tell him things that are untrue? Jesus never lied. As Peter testified, “He committed no sin, and no one ever heard a lie come from his lips” (1st Peter 2:22, TEV).
After Christ's resurrection, He was mistakenly thought of as a spirit (Lk. 24:36-37). That event would have been an opportunity and a perfect timing for him to expose his true nature. He could have told his disciples the magic words that hypostatic union believers would love to hear; what really what they think he was; that, although he was covered with flesh, he is the same unseen God whom they serve and worship.
However, quite the contrary, what Jesus exposed at that time was the glaring truth that he is different from God. In an unequivocal statement, Christ declared that He is a human being with flesh and bones; not a spirit, therefore, not God (John 4:24). Jesus also told them after His resurrection that “I am ascending to My Father and your Father, and to My God and your God” (John 20:17).
Wouldn’t it be incomprehensible then to accept the position that Christ did not reveal himself yet as God before his resurrection but identified himself as such after he arose from the dead? The statements: “My Father,” “My God,” which were constantly and repeatedly uttered by Jesus while he was still on earth even before his resurrection, reverberated once more after his resurrection.
And once more, at this time that he was talking to Mary, he told her to relay the same message to his brothers: that he was ascending to his God, their God. There was no hint whatsoever that the disciples thought differently, or that Jesus would be ascending to himself!
Incarnation is grossly unbiblical
If we would believe in Jesus the way his early disciples did, we would not be committing serious mistakes fatally committed by those who formulated the doctrine of the hypostatic union in Chalcedon. The “hypostatic union” which was developed without a clear definition of how God could have become man, has so many serious flaws that made it illogical and unacceptable.
Is it true that Christ took another form after His resurrection? No. After His resurrection, Jesus did not change His nature. He was – and is – a man. Apostle Peter, during the day of Pentecost declared:
“Men of Israel, listen to these words: Jesus the Nazarene, a man attested to you by God with miracles and wonders and signs which God performed through Him in your midst, just as you yourselves know” (Acts 2:22, NASB).
Apostle Paul, who was called by Jesus when He was already in heaven, testified that, “. . . there is one God, and one Mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus” (I Tim. 2:5, King James Version).
Obviously, if Christ had indeed converted to his alleged former state or condition, that is, of being God in heaven, then Paul would have said otherwise that “the Mediator is Christ, who is now God.” Paul, in his letter to the Romans, delineates Christ’s role in heaven:
“... Christ Jesus is He who died, yes, rather who was raised, who is at the right hand of God, who also intercedes for us.” (Romans 8:34, NASB).
If Jesus Christ were the very God of the universe, then we would not need a Mediator. Christ’s function as a Mediator for his people which he fulfills even now that he is in heaven negates the allegation that Christ exists as God in heaven.
As we move fast forward to the Day of Judgment, when “all things” shall be placed under Christ’s rule, what will the Son do which proves that he is not the Almighty God? The Bible says:
“For the scripture says, 'God put all things under his feet'. It is clear, of course, that the words ‘all things’ do not include God himself, who puts all things under Christ. But when all things have been placed under Christ's rule, then he himself, the Son, will place himself under God, who placed all things under him; and God will rule completely over all” (1st Corinthians 15:27-28, TEV).
Christ’s position before, until, and even after Judgment Day, is that of being subordinate to the Father. And the reason is clear: “The Son will place Himself under God so that God [the Father] will rule completely over all.”
The Bible never alludes to the so-called incarnation of God. After a careful examination and consultation with Scripture, the doctrine of God’s incarnation remains contrary to reason and unbiblical.
Concerning the Son, the Bible portrays Him in no uncertain terms. Instead of teaching that Christ is both God and man while He was still on earth, Apostle Paul testified that he [Jesus] is the image of the invisible God, the radiance of His glory and the exact representation of His nature (Heb. 1:3), therefore, a visible image of an unseen God.
To put in a clearer perspective, an image such as a picture, is not the very self or the nature of what it represents. The image and the form or model from where it was derived, are two different entities. Since God is invisible and powerful (John 4:24; Genesis 17:1), His Son [Jesus] represented Him on earth as a tangible proof of His holiness and power (Hebrews 1:3), clearly demonstrated through the miracles, signs and wonders which God [the Father] performed through him (Acts 2:22, TEV). The Son likewise served as man’s way to God, then and now (John 14:6; Hebrews 13:8). Being at the right hand of God in heaven, Christ always lives to make intercession for his servants (Hebrews 10:12; 7:25, NASB).
There is no defense that could be produced to support the inconceivable doctrine that Jesus is both God and man. Without a clear and explicit biblical basis, believers of such teaching have to adopt the philosophies of Tertullian and Origen. Tertullian, the one who started this mess, was a pagan philosopher who embraced Christianity but later on became a heretic. Although he departed from the Catholic Church, his writings are still being used to explain the unbiblical doctrine of Christ’s having two natures which had led Catholics and Protestants to embrace another illogical doctrine which Tertullian termed as Trinity.
To describe it in simple terms, it is in vain to call the Chalcedonian formula and its related doctrine of the Trinity as a mystery; it is an absurdity and a fallacy, therefore, grossly unbiblical and is contrary to the truth.
All scriptural quotations were taken from the New King James Version unless otherwise indicated. (2023)

JESUS CHRIST: TWO NATURES, ONE PERSON? (The Fallacy of the Doctrine of Hypostatic Union)

A certain Gabriel Darwin Lopez who claims to be an online Catholic Faith Defender and has interest in discussing about religions and church doctrines had answered the article that I had posted on my Facebook account: THE TRINITY AND THE INCARNATION: TRUTH OR FALLACY? He claims that his personal goal is to be able to share his knowledge about the Catholic Church to Catholics and non-Catholics especially those who misunderstood the Catholicism. Written below is a part of his answer:
Joe is really good in labelling the doctrines of the Catholic Church with fancy descriptions. Joe has huge guts in saying that there are no biblical verses that prove the Catholic Doctrines defined in the Church Councils instead of bringing up how Catholic Church explained their doctrine and refute it. Is it really unbiblical or Joe just refused to bring up verses that prove the hypostatic union for his deception? The Hypostatic Union is the mystery of the union of the divine nature of Christ with His human nature. Christ has two minds and two wills, united in the Divine Word.
In response to his criticism, I am posting an article that will expose the fallacy of the so-called doctrine of the Hypostatic Union. This doctrine is a humanly devised hypothesis, and a defective hypothesis cannot be saved by dubbing it as a divine mystery.
INTRODUCTION
The belief that Jesus Christ is God-Incarnate, although unbiblical, gains a large following even today. Proponents of this concept subscribe to a doctrine technically called the Hypostatic Union, meaning that there are two natures – both human and divine, subsisting in one person, the Lord Jesus Christ. For those who accept this formula, Jesus of Nazareth is one and the same person as God the Son, the Second Person of the Trinity. This concept was defined by the Council of Chalcedon in 451 A.D. The creed reads:
Following, then, the holy Fathers, we all with one voice teach that it should be confessed that our Lord Jesus Christ is one and the same Son, the Same perfect in Godhead, the Same perfect in manhood, truly God and truly man, the Same [consisting] of a rational soul and body; homoousios with the Father as to his Godhead, and the Same homoousios with us as to his manhood; in all things like unto us, sin only excepted; begotten of the Father before ages as to His Godhead, and in the last days, the Same, for us and for our salvation, of Mary the Virgin Theotokos as to his manhood; One and the same Christ, Son, Lord, Only begotten, made known in two natures [which exist] without confusion, without change, without division, without separation; the difference of the natures having been in no wise taken away by reason of the union, but rather the properties of each being preserved, and [both] concurring into one Person (prosopon) and one hypostasis – not parted or divided into two persons (prosopa), but one and the same Son and Only-begotten, the divine Logos, the Lord Jesus Christ; even as the prophets from of old [have spoken] concerning him, and as the Lord Jesus Christ himself has taught us, and as the Symbol of the Fathers has delivered to us (Grillmeier 1975:544).

WHY THE CREED WAS FORMULATED
Hick reported that the growing and developing church had to explain its beliefs to the Greek-speaking culture of the Mediterranean world, and at the same time to itself, in acceptable philosophical terms; and after Constantine’s conversion to Christianity the peace of the empire required a unitary body of Christian belief. Accordingly in 325 Constantine convened the Council of Nicaea for the purpose of restoring concord to church and empire; and it was here that the church first officially adopted from Greek culture the non-biblical concept of ousia, declaring that Jesus, as God the Son incarnate, was homoousios toi patroi – of the same substance as the Father. The political significance of this was that the Christian emperor now had the status of God’s viceroy on earth. Thus the contemporary historian Eusebius, writing about Constantine’s victory over his rival Licinius, says that Constantine and his son, under the protection of God, the universal King, with the Son of God, Saviour of all, as their leader and ally, drew up their forces on all sides against the enemies of the Deity and won an easy victory (Hick 1993:44-45).
The Nicene formulation was expanded, using the same philosophical conceptuality, at the Council of Chalcedon in 451, affirming that Christ was homoousios with the Father as to his Godhead, and at the same time homoousios with us as to his manhood . . . made known in two natures [which exist] without confusion, without change, without division, without separation . . . And it is this Chalcedonian formulation that has ever since constituted the official Christian language about Christ (Hick 1993:45).
Questions regarding the nature of God’s incarnation in Jesus also proved troublesome. The theologians of Alexandria, Egypt, tended to emphasize the divinity of Jesus at the expense of his humanity, and their frequent opponents, those of the school of Antioch, Syria, emphasized Jesus' humanity at the expense of his divinity. On the Alexandrian side, Apollinarians argued that in the human Jesus the Logos had replaced his mind or spirit. This view amounted to a denial of the full humanity of Christ. Apollinarianism was condemned at the First Council of Constantinople in 381. From the Antiochene school emerged the 5th-century heresy of Nestorianism. Nestorians held that two separate persons were united in the incarnate Christ, and they rejected the Alexandrian title of Theotokos (God-bearer) for Mary. For Nestorius, the patriarch of Constantinople (present-day İstanbul), and his followers, Mary had been the mother of the human Jesus but not of the divine-human Son. In response to the challenge of Nestorianism, the councils of Ephesus, in 431, and Chalcedon, in 451, affirmed the title Theotokos. At Chalcedon, the incarnation was defined as being of “two natures, one person”- a formula that has remained standard Christian orthodoxy.
The Chalcedonian definition itself, however, led to further disagreement; an extremist faction within the Alexandrian school argued that the incarnate Son had but a single, divine nature (Monophysitism), and in this view, again, Jesus’ humanity was compromised. By the end of the 2nd century in Alexandria, the major city of Hellenistic Egypt, the Christian catechetical school headed by Clement of Alexandria had already acquired great fame. Origen, the founder of Greek Christian theology and biblical science, followed Clement as head of the school. In the 4th and 5th centuries, two bishops of Alexandria defended Christian orthodoxy – Athanasius, against Arianism, and Cyril, against Nestorianism.
Some Egyptian Christians, however, refused to follow the decrees of the Council of Chalcedon (451), which defined the person of Jesus Christ as being “one in two natures.” The doctrine of “two natures” appeared to them to imply the existence of two Christs, divine and human, and was therefore tainted with Nestorianism. They upheld the terminology of Cyril, who had spoken of “one incarnate nature of God the Word.” Those Egyptian Christians who rejected the Council of Chalcedon—a council accepted both in Constantinople and in Rome – faced charges of Monophysitism, the belief that Christ has only one nature rather than two. Only a few Alexandrians remained faithful to Chalcedonian orthodoxy (Microsoft® Encarta® Reference Library 2003).
THE PROBLEM OF THE HYPOSTATIC UNION
The problem with the Chalcedonian concept of Christ is in the fact that the Council in effect merely asserted that Jesus was “truly God and truly man” without attempting to say how such a paradox is possible. Merely to assert that two different natures coexisted in Jesus without confusion, without change, without division, without separation, is to utter a form of words which as yet has no specified meaning. The formula sets before us a “mystery” rather than a “clear and distinct idea.” Further, this is not a divine mystery but one that was created by human beings meeting at Chalcedon in present-day Turkey in the mid-fifth century (Hick 1993:48).
IT IS A CONCEPT THAT IS AGAINST THE BIBLE
If Christ was one individual who was truly God and truly man, then the properties and activities of either the human or the divine nature might with equal truth be attributed to him. If God truly became man, while remaining God, one might say of him that God was born of the Virgin Mary, grew as a child, became an adult, and interestingly, God died on the cross. For some, they were able to accept this impossibility that God died. A Catholic Catechism reports:
“Because Jesus is one Person who lives in two distinct natures, one can truthfully say of the Son of God whatever is true of Him in either of His natures. He suffered and died in His human nature, and He is God, and so we may say that God suffered and died. This is literally true . . .” (Lawler 1976:100).
Catholic and Protestant apologists would go to the distance in trying to defend a false doctrine by accepting without any hesitation that the God of the universe died! This position greatly contradicts or truly violates one of the innate attributes of God which is immortality. The Bible says in 1 Timothy 1:17:
Now to the king of ages, immortal, invisible, the only God, be honour and glory for ever and ever. Amen. (Douay-Rheims 1899 American Edition)
THE DIVINE ATTRIBUTES OF GOD
The Bible clearly defines the attributes of God. He is immutable or unchanging (Malachi 3:6). The doctrine of Incarnation which means that God took a human form: that is, from being a pure spirit, he became flesh and blood; violates the doctrine of God’s immutability. The biblical proof that even when Christ was here on earth, God did not change his form and his true nature is clear from the teaching of Christ that God is a spirit (John 4:24), a being without flesh and bones (Luke 24:39). Apostle Paul clarified that the eternal God is invisible (1 Timothy 1:17). If it is true that Christ took a human form, the change from being a spirit to a human being entailed an enormous change and clearly demonstrates that the so-called Incarnation of God is going against the biblical teaching concerning the true nature of God.
Secondly, the Bible teaches that the true God is omniscient or all-knowing (1st John 3:20). If Christ was a God-Man on earth, there should not be any limit to his knowledge since supporters of this doctrine contend that Jesus remained God even though he became a man. If the concept is true, proponents would have to accept that Jesus had two minds, one human and one divine. A perplexing question which becomes a big dilemma for them would be to explain which mind was in control during Christ’s earthly life. Was the human mind conscious that Jesus was God the Son incarnate? Where is the dividing line between the divine mind and human mind? And what does it mean to be divine? Part of the biblical answer is that being divine consists in being the eternal, omnipotent, omniscient, omnipresent and self-existent creator of everything that exists. Was the divine mind in full operation or it took a back seat while the human mind was operating?
If the answer would be “both minds were operating simultaneously” then why would Jesus, as God the Son, being omniscient, deny any knowledge of his second coming? (Matthew 24:36 NIV). It would appear then that an all-knowing God lied in front of his disciples while doing a lecture on his second coming. That would make him a pretender and a pathological liar of the highest caliber!
The Bible emphasizes that God is omnipresent or ubiquitous (Psalm 139:8-10). This poses a problem to those who support the idea that Jesus, as a God on earth, exists in heaven as the Second Person of the Trinity due to his being an omnipresent God. How could one reconcile this idea with the biblical teaching that Christ has to ascend to heaven and be seated at the right hand of God if he was there previously? The idea of ascension suggests that he was not there yet prior to his ascension. Another intriguing situation that remains unsolved is the idea that if Jesus had a preexistence before his incarnation and dwelt on earth as both human and divine, how can the one undivided self be at once unlimited (in heaven) and limited (on earth)?
When proponents of the Chalcedonian creed are shown of biblical records that manifest the apparent contradictions of a being who is God and yet lacks the attributes of God, all that they can do is to offer analogies which fail to reach the key issue, and then appeal to mystery. As one Catholic author states:
“The Incarnation, for example, is not understood by any mortal intelligence. The Incarnation means that God became man. How this was accomplished we do not know . . . we believe it . . . not because we understand this mystery . . .” (Scott 1927:10).
Thus even if one were to grant the possibility of God becoming incarnate as a physically human being who is (always or sometimes) conscious of being divine, and thus eternal, omnipotent and omniscient, still this would not be the Jesus of the Bible. If Jesus was a God-Man on earth, how would one reconcile the statements of Christ recorded in the Scriptures that prove his glaring differences with the Father? He emphatically taught that “the Father is greater than I!” (John 14:28). Was he an inferior God compared to the Father when he was here on earth? What becomes of the Catholic doctrine that the Father and the Son are equal if one is greater than the other?
How would one reconcile the divinity of Christ with his prayer in which he didactically emphasize to his disciples that they should recognize his Father in heaven as the only true God (John 17:1-3)? Would a God on earth be praying to another God other than himself? If that was the case, one God would be here on earth and another God was in heaven – the One whom the God-Man was praying to. The truth is, Jesus prayed to God and was conscious that he was doing the will of the Father (Matthew 26:39).
If it is true that God became a man and he retained his divine nature while he was on earth, then why is there a need for him to be “anointed by God with the Holy Spirit and power?” Why would the Scriptures say that “God was with him” if it is true that he was a God on earth? (Acts 10:38).
The Bible does not mention of a divine nature within Christ which comprises the other half of his person. Instead, it emphatically asserts that “God was in Christ” (2nd Corinthians 5:19). Jesus Himself said so on numerous occasions (John 10:38; 14:10-11; 17:21). Apostle Peter echoed the same point when said that “how God anointed Jesus of Nazareth with the Holy Spirit and with power, who went about doing good and healing all who were oppressed by the devil, for God was with Him” (Acts 10:38). God, who is a separate entity from Christ, is with him by means of the Holy Spirit.
This fact was also clarified by Peter in his sermon during the day of Pentecost, in which he stressed that “Listen to these words, fellow Israelites! Jesus of Nazareth was a man whose divine authority was clearly proven to you by all the miracles and wonders which God performed through him” (Acts 2:22 TEV). Again, it is not the divine nature of Christ that performed the miracles but God himself, an omnipotent being who is distinct from Christ. It was Him who proved the divine authority of Jesus by the miracles that He performed through him.
If the assertion that the Son is one substance with the Father as regards his Godhead, then Christ would not have said, “the Father did not leave me alone” (John 8:29). His statement affirms the biblical fact that He and the Father are not of one substance (cf. Luke 24:39). This was reinforced by His admittance that “the Father is greater than I” (John 14:28). Would an intelligent mind accept the concept of hypostatic union and disregards these unequivocal statements of Jesus concerning the true God?
Thus, Chalcedonian Christology is a humanly devised hypothesis, and a defective hypothesis cannot be saved by dubbing it as a divine mystery.
Unless otherwise noted, all Scripture references were taken from the New King James Version.
REFERENCES
Grillmeier Aloys, S.J., Christ in Christian Tradition, Volume 1, Second Revised Edition, translated by John Bowden, John Knox Press, Atlanta (1975)
Hick, John, The Metaphor of God Incarnate, Christology in a Pluralistic Age, Westminster/John Knox Press, Louisville, Kentucky (1993)
Lawler, Ronald, ed., The Teaching of Christ: A Catholic Catechism for Adults, Our Sunday Visitor, Inc., Huntington, Indiana (1976)
Microsoft® Encarta® Reference Library 2003. © 1993-2002 Microsoft Corporation. All rights reserved.
Scott, Martin J., S.J., Things Catholics Are Asked About, P.J. Kennedy & Sons, New York (1927) (2023)